« 2009年10月 | トップページ | 2009年12月 »

Weird Discussion about H1N1 vaccine in Japan

In Japan, there is a weird belief about H1N1 vaccine. It is said that a vaccine of foreign manufacturer is dangerous.
This belief may originally have several assumptions; 1) a foreign vaccine would not be tested for Japanese population, 2) foreign vaccines will have some adjuvants which aren't introduced into Japan yet.
In either reasoning, it doesn't seem to be fully justifiable. Though the belief might have been established by authority in order to protect domestic manufacturers, Japanese people prefer to use a domestic product based on the brand belief in 'made in Japan'.
To my knowledge, I haven't ever heard that Japanese have different immunity to influenza vaccine (safety and efficacy). And there are many H1N1 vaccines internationally commercially available, which are tested for larger population than Japanese domestic vaccines. Even in US, the H1N1 vaccines are mainly produced by foreign manufacturers; Novartis (Switzerland), CSL (Australia), MedImmune (originally US, but now subsidiary of AstraZenecca [UK]), and Sanofi Pasteur (France).
It is difficult for me to figure out justifiable reason why Japanese need to stick to domestic vaccines.

| | コメント (2) | トラックバック (0)

Consolidate medical institutions in Japan

In connection with JAL's financial crisis, the necessity of many airports has been questioned in Japan. Basically, there is at least one airport in a prefecture in Japan. Most of the usage of the airports are commercial flights by air carrier (mainly JAL and ANA). It has been financial burden for local governments to sustain the airports.
On the other hand, the sustainability of many public hospitals has been also questioned. Especially, the hospitals managed by local governments are greatly challenged from financial standpoint. But almost all community residents want to keep the hospitals as it is, in other words, they want to have fully-equipped medical facility at hand. Though relatively fortunate medical accessibility in Japan has contributed to raise the level of public health to the first class in the world, it has caused to scatter the medical resource and patients. Consequently, the medical level couldn't reach the state-of-art level, because of the lack of sufficient patient number at each hospital.
Considering these two different problem together, I would like to propose 1) renovate prefectural airport into a fully-equipped medical facility with vast heliports, 2) downgrade local hospitals into clinics with heliport.
This will be seemingly stupid idea. But the airports will already have convenient access of public transportation to the site and vast facility of aviation. In this way, severely-diseased patients would be promptly transferred to advanced medical facility by helicopters, minimally sacrificing medical access. Rather it might be able to guarantee the state-of-art medicine to the community residents. I hope the financial burden of local governments could be collectively within almost same level, except for the initial reorganization cost.

| | コメント (6) | トラックバック (0)

It is easy to blame, but hard to accommodate.

When we face something or someone unpleasant beyond our understanding.
We tend to blame it or the person. But this blaming makes matters worse and just ends up with spoiling the relationship with the person. What we need to do is to accommodate the person. In other words, showing our compassion, we should try to understand the person.
After the listening and learning attitude, we may make the person realize something to do it better. But even at this stage, we should never try to change the person to do something specific. What we can do is just to make the person realize what we should have done and should do hereafter.
This process takes long time and a kind of hassle. In many cases, we tend to take a shortcut to say something unilaterally without appropriate interaction.
The perseverance will be an essential attribute to accommodate someone else outside ourselves.

| | コメント (2) | トラックバック (0)

« 2009年10月 | トップページ | 2009年12月 »